Tobias Smollett’s The Adventures of Roderick Random (1748) is regarded as one of the earliest, if not the first, English novel to depict openly homosexual characters. Smollett (1721-1771) was a Scottish doctor, naval surgeon and novelist who regularly spent winters in Bath from the 1740s-60s.
Partly set in Bath and drawing on people he met there, Roderick Random was Smollett’s first novel and includes several gay characters. Earl Strutwell, “notorious for a passion for his own sex”, takes advantage of the naive young Roderick in order to kiss and fondle him. Roderick writes: the Earl “pressed me to his breast with surprising emotion”.
At first Roderick does not understand Strutwell’s advances but later “his hugs, embraces, squeezes and eager looks were no longer a mystery” and Roderick realises he has been introduced to Strutwell, for his seduction, by Lord Straddle “a poor contemptible wretch who lived by borrowing and pimping to his fellow peers”. Roderick sees that Strutwell’s manservant is jealous of Roderick because previously this “valet de chamber …. had been the favourite pathic of his lord”, meaning a catamite, a youth who plays a submissive role in anal intercourse.
Although Roderick rejects Earl Strutwell’s advances, Smollett lets the Earl have a lengthy and eloquent defence of homosexual love, citing precedents of same-sex relationships in Ancient Greece and Rome. Strutwell was based on a real man. In his essay Offences Against One’s Self: Paederasty (circa 1785) philosopher and social reformer Jeremy Bentham (1748-1832) wrote:
“Much about the time when this novel was published a Scotch Earl was detected in the consummation of an amour after the manner of Tiberius* with two of his servants at the same time. The affair getting around, he found himself under the obligation of going off to the Continent where at the close of a long life he died not many years since.”
(* Tiberius: a reputedly “sexually perverse” Roman emperor).
This was John Tilney (or Tylney), 2nd Earl of Castlemaine (1712-1784) who in order to escape scandal lived in Italy for many years where he died the year before Bentham wrote Paederasty. Although not published until 1978, the essay is the first known argument for homosexual law reform in England, making Bentham an early advocate of the decriminalisation of homosexual acts.
While working as a naval surgeon’s mate on board ship Roderick meets Captain Whiffle, a wildly flamboyant gay man dressed as an effete dandy of the period in pink and gold. Tall, thin, with “meagre legs”, Whiffle fits the popular stereotype of the day of homosexual men. The surgeon, Simper, has the bedroom attached to Whiffle’s own and it is made clear no one should walk in on them unexpectedly. Simper is described as “a young man, gayly dressed, of a very delicate complexion, with a kind of languid smile on his face, which seemed to have been rendered habitual by a long course of affection”.
It could be argued therefore that Whiffle and Simper are the first gay couple in English literature. Roderick informs the reader:
“These singular regulations did not prepossess the ship’s company in his [Whiffle’s] favour but on the contrary gave scandal an opportunity to be very busy with his character, and accuse him of maintaining a correspondence with his surgeon not fit to be named”.
“Correspondence” in this context means a sexual relationship. “A crime not fit to be named” was a common euphemism for male same-sex intercourse used in the 18th and 19th centuries. Captain Whiffle is said to have been inspired by Admiral Lord Harry Powlett, 6th Duke of Bolton (1720-1794).
Smollett was obviously aware of gay men and, although he uses them for comic effect, he expected his readers to be aware as well. By reading Roderick Random gay men would have seen they were not alone and that homosexuality was widespread, even to the point that it featured in popular novels.
Smollett lived in Gay Street, Bath, from 1765-66 and also visited the then fashionable Hotwells Spa in Bristol. He travelled to Italy for his health in 1768 where he died in Monte Nero, near Livorno, Tuscany, in 1771 aged 50.
Jonathan Rowe 2024
Rictor Norton (Ed.), “Lord Strutwell, 1748”, Homosexuality in Eighteenth-Century England: A Sourcebook, 22 February 2003
http://rictornorton.co.uk/eighteen/strutwel.htm
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tobias_Smollett
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Adventures_of_Roderick_Random